Friday, May 7, 2010

"Would you kill the big guy?" from the BBC

Just heard this on the BBC and loved the poem and the moral dilemma it poses. The poem was written by Ben Motley, a rather witty producer for the BBC World Service, and read by Nigel Carrington:

Here comes a train and it’s out of control

Blasting its whistle and belching out coal

Up ahead there are five people tied to the track

It’s going too fast and there’s no turning back

A flick of a switch and the train will divert

to a line where the five people will not get hurt

But there’s one person already tied to that line

So do you flick the switch, or do you decline?


Now you are standing upon a footbridge,

As another train heads towards certain carnage

Five people tied up but you have a plan

Beside you is standing a very large man.

If you push the man onto the track down below

His massive bulk will cause the engine to slow

You’ll save five lives but the large man will die

So the question is: would you kill the big guy?


Taken from www.nigelcarrington.com in a reading for the BBC

WORLD SERVICE promoting 'Would You Kill The Big Guy.'

4 comments:

Jay Pike said...

Received an email from the author of the poem Ben Motley, helping me with corrections to some of the words I was having a hard time making out (must be my American accent getting in the way ... :) ).

Thank you Mr. Motley. Great writing, and love the poem!

jp

Mimi said...

Nice that you received correspondence from the author of this poem. Wonder how he found your website???

My answer to the poem is this: why not stop the train?

Mimi said...

Okay, I just re-read the poem and realize the train is going too fast to stop.

I retract my previous statement.

Unknown said...

Good job I like your blog.Vendant les chaussures sport, notre objectif est d’établir un réseau complet fournissant des sports chaussures pas chères. Nous avons établi une bonne relation coopérative à long terme avec des sources de fabricants et avec des agents des sports chaussures, de plus, toutes les marchandises ont la garantie de qualité et de crédibilité, donc vous êtes rassuré de les acheter et les utiliser, nous n’épargnerons aucun effort pour vous donner notre services parfaits.